A straight rural road lined with autumn trees leads toward a low sun setting on the horizon.

What Happens to Your Premium if You Raise the Deductible

Raising your deductible lowers your premium, because you agree to pay more out of pocket before coverage starts.

Compare my rates

Free to compare

A blank white folded tent card standing upright on a dark gray surface against a dark background.

A grandparent raises the deductible on an old sedan

A grandmother let her grandson drive her older sedan while he worked a summer job. She wanted to cut the premium since the car was paid off and not worth much, so she asked her insurer what raising the deductible would do. The agent walked her through a higher option and showed her the new premium side by side with the old one.

She thought about how much cash she'd want to have ready if her grandson got in a fender bender, since he was a new driver on her policy. She decided the drop in premium was worth it, because she had enough set aside to cover the higher deductible without strain, and the car itself wasn't worth a large claim anyway. She made the change, kept the savings in a separate account in case she needed it, and felt comfortable letting her grandson keep driving the car for the rest of the summer.

Is a higher deductible still a good idea with a teen driver on the policy?

It can be, but the math changes a little. A teen or young adult driver is statistically more likely to file a claim than an older, experienced driver, so you're more likely to actually face that deductible. That doesn't mean a higher deductible is wrong, it means you should weigh the savings against the real chance you'll pay it.

If the grandchild is careful, has taken driver's training, or only drives occasionally, a higher deductible can still make sense. If you're nervous about their experience level or the car gets heavy daily use, you might keep the deductible lower, even though the premium stays higher, simply because it's more likely to get used.

Front half of a dark blue SUV, showing the headlight, grille, front wheel and driver-side door, against a plain white background.

The real question isn't the savings, it's whether you'd have that deductible on hand the day you need it.

Once you know the deductible you can afford, compare quotes at that level to find the best premium for it.

An empty asphalt parking lot at night with painted white stall lines, lit by two tall pole-mounted lights on either side, with small trees and shrubs along the far edge.

Choosing a higher deductible instead of a lower one

If you do

Your premium drops right away, often enough to notice on your next bill. If a covered claim happens, you pay more upfront before coverage kicks in. You keep that difference every renewal period you don't file a claim, which adds up over years of safe driving.

If you don't

Your premium stays higher, but you pay less out of pocket the moment something happens. Small claims feel easier to file since the deductible is lower. You lose the ongoing savings, but you trade it for more predictable costs if a grandchild driving your car causes damage.

A calculator with a blank display, a black ballpoint pen, and a folded stack of banknotes on a wooden desk surface.

What actually shapes how much your premium moves

  • Size of the jump Moving from a low deductible to a noticeably higher one tends to save more than a small increase. Ask your insurer to show you two or three deductible levels side by side before deciding.
  • Your claim history A clean recent record usually means a bigger discount for raising the deductible. If you've filed claims recently, the savings may be smaller, so ask how your history factors in.
  • The car's value Raising the deductible saves more on an older or lower-value car, since any claim payout is smaller anyway. On a newer or pricier car, the deductible matters more because claims tend to be larger.
  • Who else drives it Adding a grandchild as a driver already raises your premium some, and that affects how much a higher deductible saves in dollar terms. Ask your insurer to quote the change with the grandchild already listed.
  • State and insurer rules Some states and insurers cap how high your deductible can go or require separate deductibles for certain coverages. Ask your agent what the maximum option is and whether it applies the same to every driver.
A snow-covered residential street with tire tracks, parked cars buried under snow on the left, a streetlamp, snow-laden bare trees, and houses with porches on the right.

More articles