
Should I Have Collision Insurance on a 20 Year Old Car
It usually makes sense only if the car is worth more than a few months of premiums combined, which many 20 year old cars aren't.
Free to compare

A grandfather hands down his old sedan
A grandfather had a 20 year old sedan sitting in his garage that his granddaughter needed for her first job. He still had full coverage on it out of habit, the same coverage he'd carried for two decades, and he assumed he should keep it since a new, younger driver was about to get behind the wheel.
Before adding her to the policy, he looked up what the car was actually worth. It came back low, low enough that a single year of collision premiums was close to a third of the payout he'd get if it were totaled. He dropped collision and comprehensive, kept liability coverage at a solid level since that protects against what she could do to someone else, and put the premium difference aside in case the car ever needed repairs. When she scraped a fender a few months later, he paid for it out of pocket without blinking, and he never regretted the decision.

The short version
Collision pays based on the car's value, not repair cost, so on an old car the payout is often small next to what you pay for it. Check the car's value against a year or two of premiums, and drop collision if it doesn't favor keeping it. Keep liability strong regardless.
Does dropping collision coverage put my grandchild at more risk if she crashes?
No. Collision coverage only affects whether your own car gets repaired or paid out after a crash you caused. It has nothing to do with whether other people are protected, and it has nothing to do with whether your grandchild is allowed to drive the car legally. That protection comes from liability coverage, which you should keep strong no matter how old the car is.
What changes is simply who absorbs the cost if the car itself is damaged. Without collision coverage, you pay for repairs yourself or walk away from the car if it's totaled. With it, the insurer pays out, but only up to what the car is worth, which on a 20 year old car may be a small amount. Many grandparents keep liability high and self insure the car itself once it's old enough that the payout wouldn't be worth much.
Once you know whether to keep collision on this car, compare quotes for the coverage you've decided to keep.

Keep collision coverage or drop it on this old car
If you do
You pay a premium every year for the chance that, if the car is totaled or badly damaged, the insurer cuts you a check based on current market value. On a 20 year old car that check is often modest, so you're paying ongoing money for a limited payout.
If you don't
You stop paying for collision and comprehensive, keeping only liability coverage, which protects you against damage your grandchild causes to other people or property. If the car is damaged or totaled, you cover repairs yourself or stop driving it. Most people set aside the premium savings in case repairs come up.

How to decide if collision coverage is worth it
- Look up the car's value Find what the car is actually worth right now, not what you paid for it years ago. This number is the ceiling on any collision payout, so it tells you what you're really insuring.
- Compare value to premium cost Add up what collision and comprehensive cost for a year or two and compare that total to the car's value. If the premiums are a large share of the payout, the coverage is working against you.
- Keep liability coverage strong Liability covers damage your grandchild causes to others, and that risk doesn't shrink because the car is old. Keep this coverage solid regardless of what you decide on collision.
- Check your lender's requirements If you still owe money on the car, your lender may require collision coverage no matter its age. Check your loan terms before dropping anything.
- Set aside the savings If you drop collision, put what you save aside so you can cover repairs or a replacement if something happens. This turns self insurance into a real plan instead of a gamble.



