An empty two-lane residential street canopied by large deciduous trees in full autumn color, with a house visible on the left and fallen leaves on the grass verge.

Is Hitting a Pothole a Collision or Comprehensive Claim

Pothole damage is a collision claim, because it happens when the car hits something, even if that something is a hole in the road.

Compare my rates

Free to compare

Why a pothole falls under collision coverage

Comprehensive covers things that happen to a parked or stationary car, or damage that comes from outside forces like weather, animals, theft or fire. Collision covers what happens when the car hits something or something hits it while it's moving. A pothole is part of the road, and the car driving into it is the car striking an object. That puts it squarely in collision territory, even though it feels like bad luck rather than an accident.

This matters for you because collision coverage usually carries a different deductible than comprehensive, and it's tied to the driver behind the wheel at the time. If your grandchild hits a pothole in your car, it's treated the same as any other collision, meaning it can affect the record associated with that claim and the deductible that applies.

There are edge cases. If hitting the pothole caused a tire blowout that led to hitting another object, insurers still usually trace it back to the original collision event. And if the road damage was severe enough to be considered a road hazard with a separate claim process through the state or municipality, that's a different path entirely, separate from your own policy.

Check your policy's actual definitions, since wording varies by insurer even though the general principle is the same everywhere. Also check whether your state treats pothole damage differently for liability against a government entity, since some states have specific rules about claiming against a municipality for road conditions.

A black flip car key fob and a metal car key connected by a metal key ring.

The short version

Pothole damage is a collision claim, not comprehensive, because the car hit something. If your grandchild is driving when it happens, it's treated like any other collision involving your car. Check your policy's collision deductible and ask your insurer how claims involving a listed young driver are handled.

A black flip-style car key with three buttons (lock, trunk, unlock) and an extended metal blade, lying on a dark brown wooden surface.

A grandchild hits a pothole on the way to work

Your grandson borrows your car for his new summer job and hits a deep pothole on a road he doesn't know well. The impact bends a wheel rim and damages the suspension. He's shaken but unhurt, and he calls you right away instead of trying to hide it, which matters more than people expect.

You file it as a collision claim since that's what it is, and the insurer confirms the cost of repair against your collision deductible. Because your grandson is a listed driver on your policy, the claim is processed normally, without extra scrutiny beyond what any driver would get. The repair gets approved, you pay the deductible, and the car is back on the road within a week. The experience makes clear why it mattered that he was properly added as a driver, not just borrowing the car on the side.

Compare quotes now that you know how a pothole claim affects you and your grandchild as a driver.

An empty asphalt parking lot at night with painted white stall lines, lit by two tall light poles, bordered by a row of trees under a black sky.

Whether to add your grandchild as a listed driver

If you do

If your grandchild hits a pothole or has any other collision, the claim goes through your policy the normal way, using your collision deductible. There's no question about who was driving or whether coverage applies. It's simpler, faster and avoids disputes about whether the policy should have known this person drives the car regularly.

If you don't

If your grandchild isn't listed but drives regularly anyway, an insurer can deny or delay a pothole claim once they learn an unlisted driver was behind the wheel. You may end up paying out of pocket for damage that should have been covered, and the insurer may treat the whole policy differently going forward.

A wooden clipboard holding a blank lined form with a black pen resting on it, placed on the gray hood of a car with trees reflected in the windshield.

What to sort out before handing over the keys

  • List the driver properly If your grandchild drives your car regularly, tell your insurer so they're listed. An unlisted regular driver can create coverage problems exactly when you need the coverage most.
  • Know your collision deductible A pothole claim uses your collision deductible, not comprehensive. Check what that amount is now, since it determines what you'd pay out of pocket before coverage kicks in.
  • Ask about claims and your rate A collision claim involving your car can affect your own rate, regardless of who was driving. Ask your insurer directly how a claim like this would be treated going forward.
  • Separate road damage from fault A pothole isn't anyone's fault, but it's still filed as collision rather than comprehensive. Don't assume fault-based terms apply here the way they would with another driver.
  • Check for a road claim option Some states let you file a separate claim against the government for road damage. Ask your insurer or local transportation department whether that path exists where you live.

Will my insurance rate go up if my grandchild hits a pothole?

It can, because a collision claim is tied to the policy and vehicle, not just the driver's personal record elsewhere. Whether your rate actually increases depends on your insurer's rules, your claims history, and whether your state allows rate changes after a single not-at-fault-feeling incident like this. Ask your insurer directly how they treat pothole claims specifically, since some treat them more leniently than a typical collision with another car.

Does my grandchild need their own insurance to drive my car?

Usually not, if they're listed as a driver on your policy and drive your car regularly. Coverage generally follows the vehicle, so your policy covers permitted drivers using your car. But if your grandchild has their own car or lives elsewhere full time, check with your insurer about whether a separate policy or being added to their parents' policy makes more sense for their situation.

What if my grandchild doesn't live with me but still drives my car sometimes?

It still matters to tell your insurer, because frequency of use, not just residence, is often what triggers the listed driver requirement. Occasional use during visits is usually fine without changes, but regular summer or school-year use often isn't. Ask your insurer where that line falls, since it varies, and tell them the honest pattern of how often your grandchild actually drives the car.

More articles