
What Does Merit Rating Mean in Car Insurance
A merit rating is the insurer's scorecard of your driving history, and it decides what adding your grandchild does to your price.
Free to compare

What your merit rating actually covers
- Your own driving record Merit rating starts with the tickets and accidents on your own history, not your grandchild's. Pull your driving record now so you know exactly where you stand before you add anyone.
- A new driver changes the math Adding a young driver doesn't touch your past record, but insurers weigh their inexperience heavily. Ask your insurer directly how much a grandchild driver adds before you commit.
- One at-fault claim can shift it If your grandchild causes an accident while covered under your policy, that claim can affect your merit rating going forward. Decide ahead of time who would pay for a claim so it doesn't become a surprise.
- Rating rules differ by insurer How long a violation counts against you and how much it weighs varies by company and by state. Call your insurer and ask exactly how their merit rating works before you add a driver.
- Good records can offset the risk A clean long-term record on your end can soften the impact of adding a less experienced driver. Ask if your insurer gives any credit for your history when pricing a new driver.

The short version
Merit rating is how insurers score your driving history to set your price, and it's based on your record, not your grandchild's reputation. Adding a young driver still raises risk in the insurer's eyes, which can affect your rating over time. Check your own driving record first, then ask your insurer directly how adding your grandchild would change things.

A grandmother adds her grandson before his first job
Linda's grandson Marcus moved in with her for the summer and needed to drive her car to a new job. She had a long clean driving record and worried that adding him would undo years of good rates. Before deciding anything, she called her insurer and asked how her merit rating worked and whether a new driver on the policy could change it.
The insurer explained that her own rating wouldn't drop just from adding Marcus, since merit rating reflects her history, not his. What would change was the overall price, because insurers price the household based on who's driving the car regularly. Linda decided to add him formally rather than let him drive occasionally without being listed, since an unlisted driver in an accident could have hurt her far more than the cost of adding him properly. The price went up, but her merit rating stayed intact, and she felt better knowing the coverage was real if something happened.
Now that you know how merit rating works, compare quotes to see what adding your grandchild actually costs.
Will my merit rating go down just because I add my grandchild?
No. Merit rating reflects your own driving history, made up of your tickets, accidents, and claims over time. Simply adding another driver to your policy doesn't lower that rating by itself.
What can happen is that your overall price goes up, because insurers price the policy based on everyone who drives the car, not just you. If your grandchild later causes an accident while driving your car, that claim could affect your rating going forward, the same way any claim would. So the real risk isn't the act of adding them, it's what happens after, if they're ever in an at-fault accident while covered under your policy.

Does my grandchild need their own insurance policy or can they stay on mine?
It depends on where they live and whose car they drive. If they live with you and drive your car regularly, insurers usually want them listed on your policy rather than carrying a separate one. If they live elsewhere and only drive occasionally, check with your insurer, since rules on this vary by company and by state.
How long does a claim stay on my record and affect my merit rating?
It varies by insurer and by state, so there's no single answer. Some insurers look back a few years, others longer, and the weight given to a claim can fade over time even before it disappears. Ask your insurer directly how long a claim affects your rating and whether that period differs for at-fault versus not-at-fault accidents.
Can I limit my risk if my grandchild only drives occasionally?
Yes, many insurers offer ways to cover occasional drivers without full-time rates, but the options depend on the company. Ask specifically about coverage for an occasional or secondary driver versus a primary one. What changes the answer is how often and how regularly your grandchild actually drives the car, since insurers price based on real usage, not intentions.


